Remember the original 90210? Me too, Grew up watching it, the storylines may have been a bit contrived but you went along with it. When Brenda's parents thought she shoplifted, you knew that mama and papa Walsh would find out the truth within the hour, so you sat back and enjoyed the ride. In todays version of 90210 Brenda would have shoplifted and not only that but she would be a kleptomaniac. In their bid to be shocking, producers of teen shows have lost their way.
Sex used to be a big deal, not just a plot point. When Brenda decided to have sex with Dylan on the original 90210, it played out for weeks, and every single beat was played in the story. In todays teen dramas the story is much different, I can't think of one character is a virgin. If they were that was quickly lost for a quick plot that is forgotten fairly quickly. Most of the dramas advertise the sex, Gossip Girl even went as far as to promote a menage a toi, which had no lasting effects on the show. When Joey Potter and Pacey Witter had sex for the first time on Dawsons Creek the end result was four episodes later, she thought she may be pregnant.
Maybe the reason the new crop of shows don't deal with that issue (except for Secret Life of An American Teenager) is that the actress' are way to thin. To many people this may have been a problem back in the day too, but from rewatching 4 of the 6 seasons of Dawsons Creek and the first few episodes of 90210, the girls then looked to be a healthy weight. This new crop of girls look like twigs who would break if any man or woman touches them. Half the time I'm not invested in the story because I'm busy making a cheeseburge to give to each of these actress' (thats a rant for another day I suppose)
Speaking of the way the actors look, can we please get a real life teenager here? I know that in the original set of teen dramas the actors were much older than their characters but it really sticks out with this group. Trevor Donovan is cute, slightly talented but he is no Luke Perry. They should have hired him to play a teacher who has an affair with a student. He looks so out of place working with the actors that sorta look like they could still be in high school.
Writers of the new crop of teen dramas, please feel free to use these ideas. Back in the day (this is how I know I've officially crossed the line over to old) the shows wove in socially relevant issues. Kelly Taylor, from the original 90210 was addicted to diet pills but it didn't come out in one episode, they built it and people flocked when Kelly passed out in the Peach Pit bathroom. Dawsons Creek took on student/teacher affairs with Miss Jacobs and Pacey. It was the first time a tv show, especially one aimed at teens took this issue on. They also tackled the effects of a parent cheating and divorce, among many more. The new shows could take a lesson from their predecessors. What if one of the shows took on a gay couple who were denied going to prom? Have characters on both sides of the fence, present a fair and balanced, entertaining story. It could almost be an umbrella story, You have the gay couple, then you can have the most popular couple split on whether or not the gay couple should be allowed to go. Stretch it out for a few episodes we won't mind. Or the threat of violence at school is always prevalent. Have a character be picked on, feel isolated then one day snap and plan to kill his tormentors. Difficult to handle and probably watch yes, but maybe just maybe you can shed some light on why these tragedies happen.
If you are going to tell a social story please use the old English teacher saying: "Show us, don't tell us." We know drugs are bad already. Give teens and the older audience some credit. Have the heroine start taking pain pills because she was in bad car accident (no manslaughter needed for an interesting story), then as tome goes on and she feels better she notices that she doesn't want to stop taking them. Show the first high being the best, then descend her down that dark ugly path. Since she's your heroine you can put her in pretty much every story without much complaint.
Many, many writers can't write a good social issue story. That's fine, not every show needs to do them but make up for it. Tell entertaining stories, look at classic movies like Cruel Intentions for help with plotlines. Yes yes Cruel Intentions is a remake of Dangerous Liasons but the basic story could still work. Go back and frame your stories against Shakespearean plays like Romeo and Juliet ect.
The teen drama genre can make a comeback and be classic once again but its going to take brave, talented writers to reinvigorate it. As the famous movie saying goes "If You Build It They Will Come."